No, no one's tried either of the 2 methods before. Ever.
On a more serious note, it all depends on how you learn really. Some people are fine with just reading, but I know many others benefit greatly from writing their notes out. That psych course requires you to actually understand the material and not just learn it enough that you can regurgitate some facts you read about. I strongly recommend you write out the notes and try to get a good understanding of the material itself, and not just try to read through it to get the main points only (just reading and highlighting likely won't be a good use of your time in comparison).
So even though it sucks and is time-consuming/more work, just put in that extra effort (especially if you know it works better for you). It'll pay off and you won't have to regret it later on when it's too late
Good luck!