One thing I'd recommend, is for you to double check that Anil doesn't still own the house. The fact that the house is posted under Jake doesn't really mean much to be honest, because sketchy landlords can (and do) sometimes post ads under different names when they know that students have been warned to stay away from their houses. For Anil specifically, I know he hired a manager to look after some of his properties for him and complete needed repairs. If I remember right, he sometimes posts ads under that man's name.
All in all, the point I'm trying to get across is that if you know for sure the house you're considering was one of Anil's in the past, you want to make sure he doesn't still own it now and is posting under a different name or using an agent. After all, you're pretty much right in saying Anil's one of Mac's worst landlords, so you really don't want to end up renting from him.
Good luck!