MacInsiders Logo

Similar Threads
Article Article Starter Category Comments Last Post
Who's Teaching in the Summer? britb Academics 14 04-06-2010 02:08 PM
Teaching Nino Academics 3 01-01-2009 09:30 AM
MSU Teaching Awards lorend MSU & On-Campus Services 0 11-21-2007 12:18 AM

Thunder Bay Student vs. Teaching Aid

 
Thunder Bay Student vs. Teaching Aid

According to the CBC article, a Thunder Bay student had his chin length hair chopped off, without his consent, by a teaching aid in the classroom. The article is vague as to whether the young man is of Indigenous origins but it is being assumed by many of those leaving comments on the article. This assumption is probably gained from the fact that the young man was growing it out for a performance in a traditional native dance.

The issue has become a question of whether or not this is an issue of assault or racism. The Crown states that there are no grounds for criminal charges while the boy's mother wants formal charges laid and the aid sufficiently punished for her actions.

What do you think?
Published by
kokosas's Avatar
MacInsiders Staff
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,707

Article Tools

Deleted Post
Old 05-21-2009 at 07:25 PM   #2
temara.brown
MacInsiders Staff
temara.brown's Avatar
Real name: Temara
Program: Origins Research Specialization
Year: Other
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,853

Thanked: 259 Times
Liked: 352 Times
omg who really would do that? like who cares about hair length that much these days.
  Deleted Post Deleted Post
Old 05-21-2009 at 10:45 PM   #3
DannyV
Elite Member
DannyV's Avatar
Real name: June
Program: Computer Engineering & Management
Year: Other
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 893

Thanked: 97 Times
Liked: 207 Times
It's assault
  Deleted Post Deleted Post
Old 05-22-2009 at 01:51 AM   #4
Nino
Insider Agent (IA)
Nino's Avatar
Real name: abc
Program: Business
Year: Other
Residence: Brandon Hall
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 720

Thanked: 131 Times
Liked: 91 Times
Yeah, I read that article earlier and all I really didn't know what to think about the whole thing.
They should allow the kid to give his teaching aid a really bad haircut!
  Deleted Post Deleted Post


Old 05-22-2009 at 12:45 PM   #5
gregster
Member
Real name: Greg
Program: Computer Engineering Mgt
Year: Alumni
Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 64

Thanked: 4 Times
Liked: 0 Times
It's actually 'aide'
  Deleted Post Deleted Post
Old 05-22-2009 at 02:59 PM   #6
sew12
Elite Member
sew12's Avatar
Real name: Stefanie
Program: Multimedia
Year: Fourth
Residence: SOCS
Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 1,851

Thanked: 228 Times
Liked: 473 Times
They definitely should be able to charge the teaching aide. This is definitely assault or a hate crime or something.
__________________
-Stefanie Walsh-
4th Year Multimedia 2010-2011
  Deleted Post Deleted Post
Old 05-23-2009 at 07:59 AM   #7
lorend
MacInsiders VP
lorend's Avatar
MacInsiders Staff
Real name: Danielle
Program: BA (Hons) CSCT and Anthropology, BA (Hons) English & Indigenous Studies
Year: Alumni
Residence: Whidden
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 7,615

Thanked: 913 Times
Liked: 507 Times
Thank you for posting this!!
__________________
McMaster Combined Honours Cultural Studies & Critical Theory and Anthropology: 2008
McMaster Honours English with a minor in Indigenous Studies: 2010
Carleton University Masters of Arts in Canadian Studies: 2012 (expected)

We are people of this generation, bred in at least modest comfort, housed in universities, looking uncomfortably into the world we inherit. -- Port Huron Statement



  Deleted Post Deleted Post
Old 05-23-2009 at 10:08 PM   #8
kokosas
MacInsiders Staff
kokosas's Avatar
Real name: Sabrina
Program: English and Classics
Year: Third
Residence: Edwards
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,707

Thanked: 213 Times
Liked: 23 Times
Personally, I'm with the assault charge. I don't care if hair grows back. Bruises fade, doesn't make it okay to give them to someone. I don't know if it's a racial thing and I'm hesitant to jump on that band wagon simply because it' hasn't been made clear if the child is Indigenous or not and even if he is it is possible that that had nothing to do with it. Conversely, it could have everything to do with it. The bottom line is, she should not have laid hands on him or his hair, period. If I was that mother I'd be livid too.
__________________
Sabrina Bradey
Hon. Classical History and English Language and Literature


Kayli says thanks to kokosas for this post.
  Deleted Post Deleted Post
Old 05-24-2009 at 02:27 PM   #9
arathbon
Elite Member
Real name: Alasdair
Program: Kinesiology
Year: Alumni
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 981

Thanked: 87 Times
Liked: 307 Times
Quote:
Originally Posted by sew12 View Post
They definitely should be able to charge the teaching aide. This is definitely assault or a hate crime or something.
It's not a hate crime unless they can prove that the TA did it because the kid was native.

Anyways, I don't know if its assault but its definitely firing grounds. I mean, even if the kid was growing his hair "too long", unless it was in the schools dress code it was none of their business and even if it was in the dress code there should've been a meeting with the parents. If that had happened it wouldn't have come to this anyways.
  Deleted Post Deleted Post
Old 05-29-2009 at 09:57 PM   #10
lorend
MacInsiders VP
lorend's Avatar
MacInsiders Staff
Real name: Danielle
Program: BA (Hons) CSCT and Anthropology, BA (Hons) English & Indigenous Studies
Year: Alumni
Residence: Whidden
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 7,615

Thanked: 913 Times
Liked: 507 Times
From an email forwarded from MFNSA:


> Hi everyone,
>
> I wanted to draw your attention to this important petition that I recently
> signed. It is regarding the haircut given to a 7 year old Aboriginal boy by
>
> a teacher aid in Thunder Bay. If you have not heard about this incident yet
>
> I have included some information for you below. I am sorry if you are
> getting to much information from me but I am really upset about this issue
> and I can't just let it go by. What concerns me is that the Crown has
> determined that it is not in the public interest to prosecute the TA even
> though the precedent has been set [cutting hair being an assault]. So
> according to the Thunder Bay Crown Attorney it is not in the public interest
>
> to protect a child who has been assaulted, humiliated, and traumatised by a
> person in a position of authority, in what appears to be a racially
> motivated attack. In other words, enabling racism and protecting racists is
> in the public interest, according to the Crown in Thunder Bay.
>
> "7-Year Old Anishnawbe Boy Haircut fr. Teacher Aide"
> http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/haircutofaboriginalbo y?e
>
> Please consideradding your signature, too. It's free and takes less than a
> minute of your time.
>
> NEWS REPORT
> http://www.canada.com/news/Family+betrayed+after +teacher+cuts+hair/1620958/s
> tory.html
> A teacher's aide in Thunder Bay, Ont., who last month cut the bangs of a
> First Nations student and was subsequently suspended, will not face charges,
>
> the region's acting Crown attorney said.
>
> "Based on standing Crown policy, it was determined that this act was not
> criminal, per se," David MacKenzie said Friday, adding there was no
> reasonable prospect of conviction and that it was not in the public interest
>
> to proceed in court.
>
> "This lies at the heart of the sense of First Nations that, when we speak of
>
> public interest, they are not included in that public," said Julian
> Falconer, the family's lawyer.
>
> MacKenzie said the incident occurred on April 16 when a teacher's aide, who
> thought the seven-year-old student was having trouble reading because his
> bangs were in his eyes, "apparently removed him from the classroom and
> trimmed the bangs sufficient so he could see what he was reading. . . .
> There was no suggestion of any racial implications. There was nothing
> sinister about it."
>
> "When a child is in any way physically approached by an adult, without
> consent, the suggestion of a failure to fight off the adult as an
> explanation for not prosecuting, is absurd," said Falconer.
>
> "The law is very clear in this area," said Falconer, "The removal of hair,
> without consent, is an assault."
>
> "If a First Nations teacher had taken the same actions with a non-native
> child, there would have been a swift and strong response," Falconer said.
> "The Crown attorney wouldn't be confused about the definition of consent and
>
> those non-native children would have been deemed worthy of protection.
>
> "The message here is that First Nations children are somehow less worthy of
> protection than non-native children."
>
> Falconer says the family feels betrayed by both the police and the Crown
> attorney.
>
> The school board would not say how long the suspension would last.
>
> Falconer said the parents had come to the school in the fall after the same
> teacher's aide ridiculed their older son, who also keeps his hair long. They
>
> explained that the boys wear their hair long in order to participate in
> ceremonial First Nations' dancing.
>
> MacKenzie was not aware that the family already had spoken to the teacher's
> assistant, but confirmed that she has been suspended.
>
> C Copyright (c) Canwest News Service
>
>
> _____________________ __________________________
> Indigenous Studies Events mailing list
> [email protected]
> http://mailman.McMaster.CA/mailman/listinfo/isp-l


Create a cool, new character for your Windows Live™ Messenger. Check it out
__________________
McMaster Combined Honours Cultural Studies & Critical Theory and Anthropology: 2008
McMaster Honours English with a minor in Indigenous Studies: 2010
Carleton University Masters of Arts in Canadian Studies: 2012 (expected)

We are people of this generation, bred in at least modest comfort, housed in universities, looking uncomfortably into the world we inherit. -- Port Huron Statement



  Deleted Post Deleted Post
Old 05-29-2009 at 11:24 PM   #11
DannyV
Elite Member
DannyV's Avatar
Real name: June
Program: Computer Engineering & Management
Year: Other
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 893

Thanked: 97 Times
Liked: 207 Times
Quote:
Originally Posted by lorend View Post
From an email forwarded from MFNSA:


> Hi everyone,
>
> I wanted to draw your attention to this important petition that I recently
> signed. It is regarding the haircut given to a 7 year old Aboriginal boy by
>
> a teacher aid in Thunder Bay. If you have not heard about this incident yet
>
> I have included some information for you below. I am sorry if you are
> getting to much information from me but I am really upset about this issue
> and I can't just let it go by. What concerns me is that the Crown has
> determined that it is not in the public interest to prosecute the TA even
> though the precedent has been set [cutting hair being an assault]. So
> according to the Thunder Bay Crown Attorney it is not in the public interest
>
> to protect a child who has been assaulted, humiliated, and traumatised by a
> person in a position of authority, in what appears to be a racially
> motivated attack. In other words, enabling racism and protecting racists is
> in the public interest, according to the Crown in Thunder Bay.

>
> "7-Year Old Anishnawbe Boy Haircut fr. Teacher Aide"
> http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/haircutofaboriginalbo y?e
>
> Please consideradding your signature, too. It's free and takes less than a
> minute of your time.
>
> NEWS REPORT
> http://www.canada.com/news/Family+betrayed+after +teacher+cuts+hair/1620958/s
> tory.html
> A teacher's aide in Thunder Bay, Ont., who last month cut the bangs of a
> First Nations student and was subsequently suspended, will not face charges,
>
> the region's acting Crown attorney said.
>
> "Based on standing Crown policy, it was determined that this act was not
> criminal, per se," David MacKenzie said Friday, adding there was no
> reasonable prospect of conviction and that it was not in the public interest
>
> to proceed in court.
>
> "This lies at the heart of the sense of First Nations that, when we speak of
>
> public interest, they are not included in that public," said Julian
> Falconer, the family's lawyer.
>
> MacKenzie said the incident occurred on April 16 when a teacher's aide, who
> thought the seven-year-old student was having trouble reading because his
> bangs were in his eyes, "apparently removed him from the classroom and
> trimmed the bangs sufficient so he could see what he was reading. . . .
> There was no suggestion of any racial implications. There was nothing
> sinister about it."
>
> "When a child is in any way physically approached by an adult, without
> consent, the suggestion of a failure to fight off the adult as an
> explanation for not prosecuting, is absurd," said Falconer.
>
> "The law is very clear in this area," said Falconer, "The removal of hair,
> without consent, is an assault."
>
> "If a First Nations teacher had taken the same actions with a non-native
> child, there would have been a swift and strong response," Falconer said.
> "The Crown attorney wouldn't be confused about the definition of consent and
>
> those non-native children would have been deemed worthy of protection.
>
> "The message here is that First Nations children are somehow less worthy of
> protection than non-native children."

>
> Falconer says the family feels betrayed by both the police and the Crown
> attorney.
>
> The school board would not say how long the suspension would last.
>
> Falconer said the parents had come to the school in the fall after the same
> teacher's aide ridiculed their older son, who also keeps his hair long. They
>
> explained that the boys wear their hair long in order to participate in
> ceremonial First Nations' dancing.
>
> MacKenzie was not aware that the family already had spoken to the teacher's
> assistant, but confirmed that she has been suspended.
So I guess they WILL be playing the racism card. I just don't get why as soon as there are seemingly two races involved in an incident, racism HAS to be part of the issue.

As for the Crown attorney's decision, we DON'T have all the facts. The teacher has been disciplined so why not leave it at that? If there have been previous reports of seemingly racial-motivate behaviour there should be more investigations done.

The attitude of "them" vs "us" is the one that creates so many problems.
  Deleted Post Deleted Post



Article Tools Search this Article
Search this Article:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new articles
You may not post comments
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On



McMaster University News and Information, Student-run Community, with topics ranging from Student Life, Advice, News, Events, and General Help.
Notice: The views and opinions expressed in this page are strictly those of the student(s) who authored the content. The contents of this page have not been reviewed or approved by McMaster University or the MSU (McMaster Students Union). Being a student-run community, all articles and discussion posts on MacInsiders are unofficial and it is therefore always recommended that you visit the official McMaster website for the most accurate up-to-date information.

Copyright © MacInsiders.com All Rights Reserved. No content can be re-used or re-published without permission. MacInsiders is a service of Fullerton Media Inc. | Created by Chad
Originally Powered by vBulletin®, Copyright © 2019 MH Sub I, LLC dba vBulletin. All rights reserved. | Privacy | Terms