What makes Mac Kin so much better than Waterloo Kin?
I also applied to Waterloo Kin when I was choosing universities because I was attracted to their coop option, which Mac unfortunately does not have. However, I ultimately chose Mac because of its stellar rep in its general sciences and kin program, and haven't regretted it since. Obviously I cannot make comparisons between Waterloo and Mac in terms of prof or academic quality because I haven't been to Waterloo, but based on the campus/school life in general, Mac students are generally more satisfied.
http://dailynews.mcmaster.ca /artic...n-says-report/
I have a few friends who go to Waterloo, and they do admit that their social life suffers (this probably also depends on the program). Not sure how big Waterloo kin is, but Mac kin is small (around 200 people), and I think this really enhances teaching quality. Plus, kin kids all know each other and are closer than some other programs.
Finally, no matter which school you choose, your university experience is what you make of it! All my friends are happy with their choice of university. Unless its York they chose. Not sure what to make of that :S