I must admit that I'm a little frustrated by the way this issue has been addressed by Kieran Alkerton and his team. The farmer's market is still very much a possibility. It is the night before the last day of campaigning, so I am going to try and keep this brief.
This letter was written by Derek Taylor, who was involved with the project, but certainly not at the helm. Zsuzsi Fodor, who was referenced by Derek in the letter, is one of the two students who spearheaded this project and witnessed its demise.
I spent 2.5 hours on the phone with Zsuzsi over the winter break, and she passed on 50+ emails to me detailing the entire process from start to fail; at one point, the market was completely set to launch, with an article set to be released in the Spectator. The message she left me was very clear: the farmer's market (the one she envisioned, one that would be run by students and benefit local students) is still very much a possibility, but it is going to require a strong will and plenty of determination.
In going through these emails, I found reference to Mr. Taylor:
Derek, the Director of Macgreen wants to help out and make some noise and do what his group can to get this rolling! I am going to chat with him later, any suggestions would be great.
---> From this excerpt alone, I ask - what leads you to believe that Mr. Taylor would be a better source to consult than the project leaders themselves? I think this clearly demonstrates that while he was involved in the project, his involvement was fairly peripheral.
The failing resulted from a lack of support at the administrative level; the Department of Sustainability was unwilling to push the decision because they did not want to go against the University. But that is what the MSU is there for - to fight back, to demand that students have their voice heard. This was not done, and the project fell by the wayside. I do not intend to let this happen again.
What Kieran's team has presented you with is ONE opinion from ONE person involved in the process. It should be treated as such, not as a verdict from a supreme authority. From my communications with someone heavily involved in the process, a review of the entire process from start to finish, as well as my additional research of markets at other schools, I see the market as a feasible project regardless of Mr. Taylor's statement.
Just because the University says no, does not mean we will take their response without a rebuttal. I know the farmer's market will not be an easy fight, but it is a fight I fully intend to win; it's about time we had a project like this, where student government ACTUALLY stood up and fought for something, rather than letting the University push us around.
So, how do I plan to take on hospitality services? Well, first I will continue with the work initially started by the students... they started to gather letters of support, but never put this into action. Here is a list of what they had at the time:
Tina Moffat
-Associate Professor Department of Anthropology
-member of the City of Hamilton's Community Food Security Stakeholders' Committee
Ashlee Taylor
-Director of McMaster Student Union's Diversity Services
Derek Taylor
-Director of MSU MACGreen
Robert Henderson
-Professor, Arts and Science Program and Kinesiology
Vishal Tiwari
-McMaster Student Union President
Chris Martin
-MSU VP Education
Andrew Richardson
-MSU VP Administration
Andrew Caterine
-MSU VP Finance
Caitlin Allan
-President McMaster Outdoor Club
Linda Benson
-McMaster Atheletics and Recreation
Maureen MacDonals
-Assistant Professor Kinesiology
Glenna Ciraolo
-Kinesiology
Doris Burns
-Kinesiology
Sarah Wakefield
-Professor at University of Toronto
-Chair of City of Hamilton Community Food Security Stakeholder's Committee
Karen Burson
-Coordinator of Environment Hamilton Eat Local
-member of City of Hamilton Community Food Security Stakeholder's Committee
Marsha Sulewski
-Envision Management Consulting
-Ainslie Wood Westdale Community Association and Westdale resident
Janet Woodward
-Ainslie Wood Westdale Community Association and Westdale resident
Jane Evans
-Ainslie Wood Westdale Community Association and Westdale resident
Jim Evans
-Ainslie Wood Westdale Community Association and Westdale resident
... Notice how the MSU was involved as "letters of support" but were not central to the project?
If you had serious concerns about the market, this is something that should have been brought up well in advance so that we could have had a debate about it - rather than releasing a letter from an unqualified source at the last minute in an attempt to undermine me. My promise is that my platform goals are FEASIBLE - not that they will necessarily be easy. From my experience during campaign, I would have a tremendous amount of student support in pushing the farmer's market forward. From a very informal conversation I had with the student representative on the Board of Governors, this is something he would be interested in pursuing as well.
Ms. Fodor is currently attending school in BC, but I will see if I can contact her to make a statement about the feasibility of this market...
given the tardiness of this, however, I doubt it would be much use.
Mary
www.imaginemoremary.c om