Quote:
Originally Posted by Matt Wright
I find it unsettling that so many people are taking the attitude "this is bullshit because I don't get any money"... clearly there is a demographic of students who experience financial aid and will benefit from this grant. Just because it isn't you, doesn't mean it is completely useless. STFU, enjoy university, and stop bickering.
|
While I'm not one to complain about free money, I do find a lot of things wrong with this rebate so I'll do it anyway. I'll justify it by saying that it's not really "free money" if I never should have paid it in the first place, because my tuition expenses are absurd.
1. The $160 000 cutoff is way too high. If your family is making $160 000 gross/year, then even with four kids at university you should be financially secure, unless you insist on leasing a new car every year. I'm generalizing, I know, but the point is that the cap should be lowered, or at least adjusted to accommodate the number of students per family attending university.
2. To call it a 30% rebate is almost false advertising. If the provincial tuition average is $5500, then that means there are just as many people paying $3000 for tuition as there are paying $8000. Being part of the latter demographic (and that's before supplementary fees), I'm a little annoyed that the former half is getting just as much money as I am. Would it be so difficult to rebate each student an amount proportionate to the cost of tuition?
3. To top it off, the fact that your current grants are subtracted from the $1600 is extremely counterproductive. On one hand, I can see the government wanting to spread out the aid, but on the other, if that was the goal then the students from the $160 000 households wouldn't get anything. Isn't it reasonable to assume that the students already getting aid are the ones who need it more?
3.5. One of the aforementioned grants subtracted is the Textbook and Technology Grant, which
everyone who qualifies for OSAP and goes to Mac gets. If you didn't qualify for OSAP, then why do you need the $1600 anyway?
I'm kind of neglecting the (occasionally vocal) minority of students who come from high-income families whose parents don't help them pay tuition costs, but that's a difficult situation to solve. If the province started accommodating for them, then what's to stop everyone from just lying to milk more money out of OSAP or whatever?